revisia Log in Sign up
Explore the guide

User guide · Stage 4 of 10

Criteria

Decide which studies count. revisia applies criteria in practice: the AI cannot include a study that fails a required criterion.

Open revisia
Video for Criteria · 3:35 · recorded in October 2026, so the interface may have changed slightly. Audio is in Spanish. See them all.
Why they matter so much

Criteria are the rules that decide which studies enter and which stay out. Written before screening, they make screening reproducible: someone else with the same rules would reach the same place. They do not change the search, which is already done: they decide what stays when you screen.

Define the criteria

  1. Let the AI propose. As soon as you enter, the AI starts proposing criteria from your question. You see the notice “Thinking through the criteria…” with a counter. It can take a little while. You can close the tab: the job continues on the server and the proposal waits for you here. For another proposal, select “Suggest criteria (AI)”.
  2. Review the “Suggested criteria”. Each comes with its stage, whether it is required and a “Why” line with the reason. If your protocol already set the design or the comparator, a “Your protocol” label sits alongside so you can compare.
  3. You choose. Add them one by one with “Add”, select “Add all”, or dismiss the whole proposal with “Dismiss”. The proposal is saved: what you do not add keeps waiting for you.
  4. Write your own if any are missing. Under “Add criterion”, give a short name, such as “population”, and screening instructions: how to decide whether a study meets it. Make them concrete and checkable. “Adults aged 18 or over” can be checked; “appropriate population” cannot.
  5. Say what to do with silence. Most often the abstract does not mention what you are looking for. If the criterion says “if not specified, mark uncertain”, the study goes to your review queue instead of being excluded.
  6. Decide “Required” or “Optional”. A study that fails a required criterion cannot be included. Optional criteria inform, but do not exclude on their own.
  7. Check the two columns. On the left, “Inclusion criteria”: what you require. On the right, “Exclusion criteria”, generated from your required criteria: a study is out as soon as it fails any of them. Each card has two toggles, so one click switches between “Abstract” and “Full text”, or between “Required” and “Optional”. “Edit” rewrites the instructions on the card itself.
  8. Select “Approve & continue”. You need at least one “Abstract” criterion: it drives screening.

Abstract or full text

Every criterion is judged at one stage, and this is the most important decision on the screen.

  • “Abstract” for anything you can check from the title and abstract. These criteria apply in stage 5 screening.
  • “Full text” for details that require the whole article: randomisation method, exact dose or measurement instrument. They apply at stage 7.
Practical rule

If the answer is not in the abstract, the criterion belongs to full text. Forcing it into the first phase causes exclusions that you later need to rescue one by one.

Changing criteria after screening

You can, and it is documented. Edit the criterion at this stage. Once screening has run, the name is fixed, because saved verdicts and the exclusions table use it; if you need another name, add a new criterion. The text can change, and you can write the reason for the change: it goes to PRISMA and is declared as an amendment in the manuscript.

  • Each change is a version. Each change after screening is saved as a new version (v1, v2…). “Criteria history” shows them all, and “Go back to this version” restores an earlier one. Going back deletes nothing: it creates a new version equal to it.
  • What needs no AI is recalculated on its own. Switching a criterion from required to optional, or deleting it, is recalculated at no cost.
  • Everything else asks you to screen again. Back at the screening stage you will see a band saying how many verdicts come from the previous criteria, and the “Screen again…” button. You choose the scope: the affected records (those with a “no” or “uncertain” on the criterion you changed, recommended) or everything the AI judged (if you made it stricter or changed several). Your human decisions are not touched.
  • The quota counts. Every re-screened record uses your plan's quota. If you have none left, “Review the affected by hand” sends them to your queue, with the previous judgement visible.

Troubleshooting

  • It will not let me approve. An “Abstract” criterion is missing. Mark at least one with that stage.
  • The proposal is slow. It can take a little while. You can close the tab and come back: the proposal waits for you.
  • One criterion excludes too much. It usually does not say what to do when information is absent. Add “if not specified, mark uncertain” so ambiguous studies go to your queue instead of being excluded.
  • I want to rename a criterion that has been screened. The name is fixed after screening. Add a new criterion with the name you want and make the old one optional or delete it.
Still stuck?

Ask the assistant inside your project or email us at equipo@revisia.es.